Bill Donohue began his Aug. 26 CNSNews.com column by ranting:
Aside from pro-abortion activists, everyone who has taken a serious look at the writings and speeches of Margaret Sanger admits that she was racist. Indeed, her beliefs were just as racist as those of any Imperial Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan. The evidence is overwhelming. Yet there are those who are still trying to rescue her legacy. Worse, some are in total denial about her racism.
As we’ve pointed out, while Sanger was very much a eugenicist, there’s little evidence that it was racially driven, or that Sanger was any more racist than the typical person of her day. But Donohue will insist on making that point anyway.
He asserted, as evidence of Sanger’s alleged virulent racism, that “Even today, almost 8 in 10 Planned Parenthood abortion clinics are in minority neighborhoods,” a claim he sourced from anti-abortion activist Abby Johnson’s speech at the Republian National Convention — a claim that is not true.
Donohue went on to ask his readers to “consider what Sanger said in her book, ‘Women, Morality, and Birth Control’: ‘We don’t want the word to get out that we want to exterminate the Negro population.'”
Not only does that phrase not appear in that book, the word “Negro” appears nowhere in it, period. The phrase actually came from a 1939 letter from Sanger to a doctor participating in her project to bring birth control to the black community; as fact-checkers have pointed out, the quote is in reference to encouraging black doctors and ministers to let black women know that Sanger’s birth-control campaign targeting blacks was not a Jim Crow-like action.
So: Donohue writes a column based on a flawed premise, and gets facts wrong in trying to bolster that premise. And we’re supposed to trust what he says?